New York: The US won a long-running trade case challenging subsidies that European Union nations had provided Airbus SE to develop jetliners, costing Boeing Co. sales.
The World Trade Organisation final ruling Tuesday paves the way for US President Donald Trump to impose retaliatory sanctions. An appellate panel for the international trade body affirmed a 2016 ruling that the EU had failed to eliminate unfair funding for two Airbus models.
“Today’s final ruling sends a clear message: disregard for the rules and illegal subsidies are not tolerated. The commercial success of products and services should be driven by their merits and not by market-distorting actions,” said Boeing Chief Executive Officer Dennis Muilenburg.
Later this year, the WTO is expected to issue a final ruling in a separate case in which the EU challenged billions of dollars in US aid to Boeing.
The litigation adds to the tension between the US and Europe, two once-cooperative trade partners that are already sparring over Trump’s steel and aluminium tariffs and his decision to back out of a nuclear treaty with Iran.
The next stage of the 14-year battle will be over the size of the tariffs the US will be allowed to impose to compensate for lost exports. The Geneva-based WTO can’t force nations or companies to drop payments that violate trade rules, but it can authorise retaliatory measures to pressure governments into complying with its rulings.
The decision Tuesday affirmed a ruling that EU member states have failed to adequately remedy market-distorting aid for the launch of Airbus’s A380 superjumbo, infrastructure support and equity investments that unfairly benefited the plane maker. The bloc compounded the issue with below-market loans for the planemaker’s marquee A350 jetliner.
The size of US tariffs to be allowed will be determined through a WTO arbitration process, and will be based on the annual harm to US and Boeing — losses that the US had previously pegged as ranging from $7 billion (Dh25 billion) to $10 billion a year.
Airbus said in a statement released after the WTO ruling that it would take steps to ensure the aid complies with the decision, and predicted any eventual sanctions would be minor.
“Despite Boeing’s rhetoric, it is clear that their position today is straightforward healthy: they have half the market and a full order book, they have clearly not been damaged by Airbus repayable loans,” Airbus CEO Tom Enders said.
The US and the EU have spent more than a decade wrangling over various government efforts to help Chicago-based Boeing and Toulouse, France-based Airbus defray billions of dollars in costs to design and produce commercial aircraft. Later this year, a separate WTO compliance panel is expected to deliver its decision as to whether the US complied with the terms of a 2012 ruling against illegal US tax subsidies that gave Boeing an unfair advantage.
The trade court in September ruled in Boeing’s favour in another case brought by the EU, overturning an earlier finding that $8.7 billion in state aid to Boeing for making the 777X in Washington was a prohibited subsidy.